PAL modesplit: hardware-checked upstream expectations

Automatic reference audit · Exact bindings, source hashes, commands, coordinates and debugger observations · Unchanged upstream hardware-check notes

JSIDPlay2 matches all 104448 logical pixels of each upstream PAL image, under both C64 and C64C machine presets with the selected VIC. Fresh VICE 3.7.1 and 3.10 captures agree with each other, differing from the upstream expectations by 348 MOS6569 pixels and 124 MOS8565 pixels.

The program, both PNGs and hardware-check notes are byte-identical to upstream r45900 (2025-12-15), commit 6dee9e41cad26e8bb752eab8c3cf7e5f9cb88489. The author describes crafted reference images checked against a Breadbox and C64C. These are software expectations; this audit adds no physical recording or new chip-sample qualification.

The debugger traces an older-chip bitmap-to-ECM transition at (293,44): bitmap decoding falls at dot 5, producing color 14; VICE produces 0. At (152,44), MOS8565’s delayed transition retains an invalid-mode first pixel, producing color 0; VICE produces 6. Full-frame native comparisons independently confirm all remaining pixels.

The two PAL tests retain these exact upstream expectations, with guards on program, image and provenance bytes, scenario IDs, chip/model options and deadlines. Fresh VICE captures remain visible comparisons. The emulator core and guest program are unchanged; no pixels are masked or tolerated.

The focused run records 177 cases: 173 passes, three existing NTSC failures and one existing unsupported-NTSC skip. Those separate NTSC assertions remain active. Complete test report

MOS6569R3 / PAL — 348 VICE comparison pixels; whole upstream image passes
Upstream r45900: crafted expectation checked against hardware
Upstream r45900: crafted expectation checked against hardware
JSIDPlay2: all 104448 pixels match the upstream expectation
JSIDPlay2: all 104448 pixels match the upstream expectation
VICE 3.7.1: two matching independent launches
VICE 3.7.1: two matching independent launches
VICE 3.10: two matching independent launches
VICE 3.10: two matching independent launches
VICE versus upstream/JSIDPlay2: 348 differing pixels
VICE versus upstream/JSIDPlay2: 348 differing pixels
MOS8565 / PAL — 124 VICE comparison pixels; whole upstream image passes
Upstream r45900: crafted expectation checked against hardware
Upstream r45900: crafted expectation checked against hardware
JSIDPlay2: all 104448 pixels match the upstream expectation
JSIDPlay2: all 104448 pixels match the upstream expectation
VICE 3.7.1: two matching independent launches
VICE 3.7.1: two matching independent launches
VICE 3.10: two matching independent launches
VICE 3.10: two matching independent launches
VICE versus upstream/JSIDPlay2: 124 differing pixels
VICE versus upstream/JSIDPlay2: 124 differing pixels