{
  "schemaVersion": 1,
  "purpose": "comparison",
  "scenarioId": "143ccd536995c08a",
  "program": {
    "id": "143ccd536995c08a",
    "path": "VICII/split-tests/modesplit/modesplit.prg",
    "kind": "screenshot",
    "cycles": 20000000,
    "options": [
      "vicii-ntsc"
    ],
    "model": "C64",
    "clock": "NTSC",
    "expected": "pass",
    "reference": "VICII/split-tests/modesplit/references/modesplit.prg-ntsc.png"
  },
  "programSha256": "30155e1249056589f4139bbf5f31d138cca723febeac550ef4e44a4a73214a37",
  "testProgramsRevision": "e7aa2aab2e5ac4208fcd53acd4bb237902149e4f",
  "pinnedUpstream": {
    "commit": "6dee9e41cad26e8bb752eab8c3cf7e5f9cb88489",
    "revision": "r45900",
    "source": "https://github.com/libsidplayfp/VICE-testprogs/commit/6dee9e41cad26e8bb752eab8c3cf7e5f9cb88489",
    "ntscReferenceAndPhotoByteIdentical": true,
    "referenceAuthored": "2025-12-15",
    "photoVisibleProgramRevision": "R01",
    "currentProgramRevision": "R04",
    "physicalProgramSha256": null
  },
  "decision": "Unresolved: retain the existing emulator and both strict reference contracts; no tolerance, pixel mask or oracle replacement.",
  "normalization": "Exact logical VIC palette indices, accepting documented palette aliases. Crop 12 top rows from 384x247 source images; retain 384x235 JSIDPlay2 output.",
  "comparison": {
    "jsidVsUpstream": 134,
    "jsidVsVice": 192,
    "upstreamVsVice": 326,
    "overlappingDisagreements": 0,
    "graphicsFetchRegionVsUpstream": 108,
    "otherUpstreamDifferences": 26,
    "allNtscMachinePresetsIdentical": true
  },
  "runtime": {
    "events": {
      "path": "runtime-events.json",
      "sha256": "bd6fe438cc183afa52645252e92508a9777c3241bc3bbe3851204796cd9f0a5f"
    },
    "terminalCycle": 3025209,
    "callPath": [
      "MOS6567.doPHI1Fetch:83",
      "MOS6567.lambda$new$0:120",
      "Event$1.event:65",
      "EventScheduler.clock:265",
      "Player.play:1031"
    ],
    "bitmap": {
      "raster": 76,
      "internalCycle": 41,
      "d011": "0x3b",
      "previousD011Mode": "0x40",
      "address": "0x0441",
      "data": "0x5f",
      "vcBefore": 136,
      "rc": 1,
      "renderedPixel": [
        162,
        36
      ],
      "jsidVicColor": 5,
      "upstreamVicColor": 6,
      "viceVicColor": 5
    },
    "text": {
      "raster": 124,
      "internalCycle": 27,
      "d011": "0x5b",
      "previousD011Mode": "0x00",
      "address": "0x1af9",
      "data": "0x99",
      "vcBefore": 362,
      "rc": 1,
      "followingAddress": "0x18f9",
      "followingData": "0x10",
      "renderedPixel": [
        48,
        84
      ],
      "jsidVicColor": 14,
      "upstreamVicColor": 14,
      "viceVicColor": 1
    }
  },
  "historicalControl": {
    "program": "src/test/resources/vic/ntsc-videomode-2019/videomode-v_ntsc.prg",
    "programSha256": "ce06453ef618b815535f27d3454d84d1ec57570c67b6b81c62d53ad47ae53aed",
    "differingPixels": 0,
    "limitation": "Hand-tuned 2019 software expectation; the physical recording binary hash is unknown. This is not new hardware qualification."
  },
  "captures": [
    {
      "key": "143ccd536995c08a",
      "version": "3.7.1",
      "checkpoint": 3623599,
      "captureCycle": 3658330,
      "imageSha256": "ae684d14b56f723a7a711ff0685c545057e73bc818870659de53fc3f2618fcdd",
      "images": [
        {
          "path": "images/vice-3.7.1-1.png",
          "sha256": "ae684d14b56f723a7a711ff0685c545057e73bc818870659de53fc3f2618fcdd"
        },
        {
          "path": "images/vice-3.7.1-2.png",
          "sha256": "ae684d14b56f723a7a711ff0685c545057e73bc818870659de53fc3f2618fcdd"
        }
      ],
      "commands": {
        "checkpoint": [
          "/usr/bin/stdbuf",
          "-oL",
          "-eL",
          "/usr/bin/x64sc",
          "-console",
          "-default",
          "+saveres",
          "-directory",
          "/home/ken/git/jsidplay2/target/vice-screenshot-reference-captures/roms:/usr/share/vice",
          "-seed",
          "1",
          "-model",
          "ntsc",
          "-ntsc",
          "-VICIImodel",
          "6567",
          "-cia1model",
          "0",
          "-cia2model",
          "0",
          "-kernal",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/kernal.bin",
          "-basic",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/basic.bin",
          "-chargen",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/char.bin",
          "-dos1541",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1541.bin",
          "-dos1541II",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1541-2.bin",
          "-dos1571",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1571.bin",
          "-dos1581",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1581.bin",
          "-sidenginemodel",
          "257",
          "-sidextra",
          "0",
          "-drive8type",
          "0",
          "-sounddev",
          "dump",
          "-soundarg",
          "/dev/null",
          "-soundrecdev",
          "wav",
          "-soundrecarg",
          "/tmp/jsidplay2-ntsc-modesplit-review/143ccd536995c08a-3.7.1/capture.wav",
          "-warp",
          "-speed",
          "100",
          "+autostart-warp",
          "-sound",
          "-jamaction",
          "5",
          "-autostartprgmode",
          "1",
          "+autostartwithcolon",
          "-VICIIfilter",
          "0",
          "-VICIIborders",
          "0",
          "-VICIIextpal",
          "-VICIIpalette",
          "pepto-ntsc.vpl",
          "-VICIIsaturation",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIbrightness",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIcontrast",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIgamma",
          "1000",
          "-VICIItint",
          "1000",
          "-debugcart",
          "-limitcycles",
          "14000000",
          "/home/ken/git/jsidplay2/src/test/resources/VICE-testprogs-master/VICII/split-tests/modesplit/modesplit.prg"
        ],
        "1": [
          "/usr/bin/stdbuf",
          "-oL",
          "-eL",
          "/usr/bin/x64sc",
          "-console",
          "-default",
          "+saveres",
          "-directory",
          "/home/ken/git/jsidplay2/target/vice-screenshot-reference-captures/roms:/usr/share/vice",
          "-seed",
          "1",
          "-model",
          "ntsc",
          "-ntsc",
          "-VICIImodel",
          "6567",
          "-cia1model",
          "0",
          "-cia2model",
          "0",
          "-kernal",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/kernal.bin",
          "-basic",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/basic.bin",
          "-chargen",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/char.bin",
          "-dos1541",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1541.bin",
          "-dos1541II",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1541-2.bin",
          "-dos1571",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1571.bin",
          "-dos1581",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1581.bin",
          "-sidenginemodel",
          "257",
          "-sidextra",
          "0",
          "-drive8type",
          "0",
          "-sounddev",
          "dump",
          "-soundarg",
          "/dev/null",
          "-soundrecdev",
          "wav",
          "-soundrecarg",
          "/tmp/jsidplay2-ntsc-modesplit-review/143ccd536995c08a-3.7.1/capture.wav",
          "-warp",
          "-speed",
          "100",
          "+autostart-warp",
          "-sound",
          "-jamaction",
          "5",
          "-autostartprgmode",
          "1",
          "+autostartwithcolon",
          "-VICIIfilter",
          "0",
          "-VICIIborders",
          "0",
          "-VICIIextpal",
          "-VICIIpalette",
          "pepto-ntsc.vpl",
          "-VICIIsaturation",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIbrightness",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIcontrast",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIgamma",
          "1000",
          "-VICIItint",
          "1000",
          "-limitcycles",
          "3658330",
          "-exitscreenshot",
          "/tmp/jsidplay2-ntsc-modesplit-review/143ccd536995c08a-3.7.1/1.png",
          "/home/ken/git/jsidplay2/src/test/resources/VICE-testprogs-master/VICII/split-tests/modesplit/modesplit.prg"
        ],
        "2": [
          "/usr/bin/stdbuf",
          "-oL",
          "-eL",
          "/usr/bin/x64sc",
          "-console",
          "-default",
          "+saveres",
          "-directory",
          "/home/ken/git/jsidplay2/target/vice-screenshot-reference-captures/roms:/usr/share/vice",
          "-seed",
          "1",
          "-model",
          "ntsc",
          "-ntsc",
          "-VICIImodel",
          "6567",
          "-cia1model",
          "0",
          "-cia2model",
          "0",
          "-kernal",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/kernal.bin",
          "-basic",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/basic.bin",
          "-chargen",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/char.bin",
          "-dos1541",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1541.bin",
          "-dos1541II",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1541-2.bin",
          "-dos1571",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1571.bin",
          "-dos1581",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1581.bin",
          "-sidenginemodel",
          "257",
          "-sidextra",
          "0",
          "-drive8type",
          "0",
          "-sounddev",
          "dump",
          "-soundarg",
          "/dev/null",
          "-soundrecdev",
          "wav",
          "-soundrecarg",
          "/tmp/jsidplay2-ntsc-modesplit-review/143ccd536995c08a-3.7.1/capture.wav",
          "-warp",
          "-speed",
          "100",
          "+autostart-warp",
          "-sound",
          "-jamaction",
          "5",
          "-autostartprgmode",
          "1",
          "+autostartwithcolon",
          "-VICIIfilter",
          "0",
          "-VICIIborders",
          "0",
          "-VICIIextpal",
          "-VICIIpalette",
          "pepto-ntsc.vpl",
          "-VICIIsaturation",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIbrightness",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIcontrast",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIgamma",
          "1000",
          "-VICIItint",
          "1000",
          "-limitcycles",
          "3658330",
          "-exitscreenshot",
          "/tmp/jsidplay2-ntsc-modesplit-review/143ccd536995c08a-3.7.1/2.png",
          "/home/ken/git/jsidplay2/src/test/resources/VICE-testprogs-master/VICII/split-tests/modesplit/modesplit.prg"
        ]
      },
      "logs": [
        {
          "path": "logs/vice-3.7.1-checkpoint.log",
          "sha256": "28ee2b6d6fc8fef087924808e29a54b3adbf263e71b55ab16ed26410322c10d7"
        },
        {
          "path": "logs/vice-3.7.1-1.log",
          "sha256": "3723e50c7eb0c051fe7cf43796e22d1b3389fd2d8c457c4fee8860285ea634eb"
        },
        {
          "path": "logs/vice-3.7.1-2.log",
          "sha256": "6ab9f2b4f963b89d407bb5458f039c5284849731e0fd9916e7e2630a88cfa664"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "key": "143ccd536995c08a",
      "version": "3.10",
      "checkpoint": 3674884,
      "captureCycle": 3709615,
      "imageSha256": "ae684d14b56f723a7a711ff0685c545057e73bc818870659de53fc3f2618fcdd",
      "images": [
        {
          "path": "images/vice-3.10-1.png",
          "sha256": "ae684d14b56f723a7a711ff0685c545057e73bc818870659de53fc3f2618fcdd"
        },
        {
          "path": "images/vice-3.10-2.png",
          "sha256": "ae684d14b56f723a7a711ff0685c545057e73bc818870659de53fc3f2618fcdd"
        }
      ],
      "commands": {
        "checkpoint": [
          "/usr/bin/stdbuf",
          "-oL",
          "-eL",
          "/tmp/jsidplay2-vice-build/vice-3.10/src/x64sc",
          "-console",
          "-default",
          "-directory",
          "/home/ken/git/jsidplay2/target/vice-screenshot-reference-captures/roms:/tmp/jsidplay2-vice-build/vice-3.10/data",
          "-seed",
          "1",
          "-model",
          "ntsc",
          "-ntsc",
          "-VICIImodel",
          "6567",
          "-cia1model",
          "0",
          "-cia2model",
          "0",
          "-kernal",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/kernal.bin",
          "-basic",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/basic.bin",
          "-chargen",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/char.bin",
          "-dos1541",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1541.bin",
          "-dos1541II",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1541-2.bin",
          "-dos1571",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1571.bin",
          "-dos1581",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1581.bin",
          "-sidenginemodel",
          "257",
          "-sidextra",
          "0",
          "-drive8type",
          "0",
          "-sounddev",
          "dump",
          "-soundarg",
          "/dev/null",
          "-soundrecdev",
          "wav",
          "-soundrecarg",
          "/tmp/jsidplay2-ntsc-modesplit-review/143ccd536995c08a-3.10/capture.wav",
          "-warp",
          "-speed",
          "100",
          "+autostart-warp",
          "-soundwarpmode",
          "1",
          "-sound",
          "-jamaction",
          "5",
          "-autostartprgmode",
          "1",
          "+autostartwithcolon",
          "-VICIIfilter",
          "0",
          "-VICIIborders",
          "0",
          "-VICIIextpal",
          "-VICIIpalette",
          "pepto-ntsc.vpl",
          "-VICIIsaturation",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIbrightness",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIcontrast",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIgamma",
          "1000",
          "-VICIItint",
          "1000",
          "-debugcart",
          "-limitcycles",
          "14000000",
          "/home/ken/git/jsidplay2/src/test/resources/VICE-testprogs-master/VICII/split-tests/modesplit/modesplit.prg"
        ],
        "1": [
          "/usr/bin/stdbuf",
          "-oL",
          "-eL",
          "/tmp/jsidplay2-vice-build/vice-3.10/src/x64sc",
          "-console",
          "-default",
          "-directory",
          "/home/ken/git/jsidplay2/target/vice-screenshot-reference-captures/roms:/tmp/jsidplay2-vice-build/vice-3.10/data",
          "-seed",
          "1",
          "-model",
          "ntsc",
          "-ntsc",
          "-VICIImodel",
          "6567",
          "-cia1model",
          "0",
          "-cia2model",
          "0",
          "-kernal",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/kernal.bin",
          "-basic",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/basic.bin",
          "-chargen",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/char.bin",
          "-dos1541",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1541.bin",
          "-dos1541II",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1541-2.bin",
          "-dos1571",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1571.bin",
          "-dos1581",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1581.bin",
          "-sidenginemodel",
          "257",
          "-sidextra",
          "0",
          "-drive8type",
          "0",
          "-sounddev",
          "dump",
          "-soundarg",
          "/dev/null",
          "-soundrecdev",
          "wav",
          "-soundrecarg",
          "/tmp/jsidplay2-ntsc-modesplit-review/143ccd536995c08a-3.10/capture.wav",
          "-warp",
          "-speed",
          "100",
          "+autostart-warp",
          "-soundwarpmode",
          "1",
          "-sound",
          "-jamaction",
          "5",
          "-autostartprgmode",
          "1",
          "+autostartwithcolon",
          "-VICIIfilter",
          "0",
          "-VICIIborders",
          "0",
          "-VICIIextpal",
          "-VICIIpalette",
          "pepto-ntsc.vpl",
          "-VICIIsaturation",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIbrightness",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIcontrast",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIgamma",
          "1000",
          "-VICIItint",
          "1000",
          "-limitcycles",
          "3709615",
          "-exitscreenshot",
          "/tmp/jsidplay2-ntsc-modesplit-review/143ccd536995c08a-3.10/1.png",
          "/home/ken/git/jsidplay2/src/test/resources/VICE-testprogs-master/VICII/split-tests/modesplit/modesplit.prg"
        ],
        "2": [
          "/usr/bin/stdbuf",
          "-oL",
          "-eL",
          "/tmp/jsidplay2-vice-build/vice-3.10/src/x64sc",
          "-console",
          "-default",
          "-directory",
          "/home/ken/git/jsidplay2/target/vice-screenshot-reference-captures/roms:/tmp/jsidplay2-vice-build/vice-3.10/data",
          "-seed",
          "1",
          "-model",
          "ntsc",
          "-ntsc",
          "-VICIImodel",
          "6567",
          "-cia1model",
          "0",
          "-cia2model",
          "0",
          "-kernal",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/kernal.bin",
          "-basic",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/basic.bin",
          "-chargen",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/char.bin",
          "-dos1541",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1541.bin",
          "-dos1541II",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1541-2.bin",
          "-dos1571",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1571.bin",
          "-dos1581",
          "src/main/resources/libsidplay/roms/c1581.bin",
          "-sidenginemodel",
          "257",
          "-sidextra",
          "0",
          "-drive8type",
          "0",
          "-sounddev",
          "dump",
          "-soundarg",
          "/dev/null",
          "-soundrecdev",
          "wav",
          "-soundrecarg",
          "/tmp/jsidplay2-ntsc-modesplit-review/143ccd536995c08a-3.10/capture.wav",
          "-warp",
          "-speed",
          "100",
          "+autostart-warp",
          "-soundwarpmode",
          "1",
          "-sound",
          "-jamaction",
          "5",
          "-autostartprgmode",
          "1",
          "+autostartwithcolon",
          "-VICIIfilter",
          "0",
          "-VICIIborders",
          "0",
          "-VICIIextpal",
          "-VICIIpalette",
          "pepto-ntsc.vpl",
          "-VICIIsaturation",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIbrightness",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIcontrast",
          "1000",
          "-VICIIgamma",
          "1000",
          "-VICIItint",
          "1000",
          "-limitcycles",
          "3709615",
          "-exitscreenshot",
          "/tmp/jsidplay2-ntsc-modesplit-review/143ccd536995c08a-3.10/2.png",
          "/home/ken/git/jsidplay2/src/test/resources/VICE-testprogs-master/VICII/split-tests/modesplit/modesplit.prg"
        ]
      },
      "logs": [
        {
          "path": "logs/vice-3.10-checkpoint.log",
          "sha256": "8492c41512b2df4c56459a26433cc95d6cfa65839aff2a3725930f6fc6d2c19f"
        },
        {
          "path": "logs/vice-3.10-1.log",
          "sha256": "57260a10059c8d464fcb9de14e244e0fab0387f14f27f964c7eb6849383c8f3d"
        },
        {
          "path": "logs/vice-3.10-2.log",
          "sha256": "beee03a17c4d910f60d2e8874cca86eb525b74b8878dee7c28b204a52a5fe118"
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "files": {
    "jsid": {
      "path": "images/jsid-C64.png",
      "sha256": "e5b5a021adc39b929041e87ea1821909c47b4f92e4681813e0f501638f5596f5"
    },
    "upstream": {
      "path": "images/upstream-r45900-ntsc.png",
      "sha256": "a188f824f04e5863c52d9716565c69238b5ab4bf083632ff73939a022da4ed93"
    },
    "publishedVice": {
      "path": "images/published-vice-3.10.png",
      "sha256": "6a4b2a02832ce333beb58d2378fe4683994d9a56df8e2140652c8c0f9748171a"
    },
    "photo": {
      "path": "images/upstream-6567r8-R01.jpg",
      "sha256": "4afd289c10af9a305a590822d70b13c002fb7aa8b30a7ae5b1bd702d414a589d"
    },
    "notes": {
      "path": "upstream-README.txt",
      "sha256": "6c6279c45b4520dbdf475e0aa557a0a9d1a17394005594c518409eb6c3380584"
    },
    "runtime": {
      "path": "runtime-events.json",
      "sha256": "bd6fe438cc183afa52645252e92508a9777c3241bc3bbe3851204796cd9f0a5f"
    },
    "historicalActual": {
      "path": "images/historical-videomode-v-actual.png",
      "sha256": "39c2097ff1fa38f0e253637131b908c34be8fe9eb0b7da3df44f016746394433"
    },
    "historicalExpected": {
      "path": "images/historical-videomode-v-reference.png",
      "sha256": "f97b8851c2eec544d1878796d3152bee0f6589e053f6770dcf414ff1beb9df79"
    },
    "jsid-C64": {
      "path": "images/jsid-C64.png",
      "sha256": "e5b5a021adc39b929041e87ea1821909c47b4f92e4681813e0f501638f5596f5"
    },
    "jsid-C64C": {
      "path": "images/jsid-C64C.png",
      "sha256": "e5b5a021adc39b929041e87ea1821909c47b4f92e4681813e0f501638f5596f5"
    },
    "logical-jsid": {
      "path": "images/logical-jsid.png",
      "sha256": "56262ab526ca13a934a803ff2913d0c5aa184dea07a0de9b0b22b4b7e9ca071b"
    },
    "logical-upstream": {
      "path": "images/logical-upstream.png",
      "sha256": "b45da7f5b1d454288e58b184ff5a43e8b0558bd3140c1bc5a36f08c9a6659837"
    },
    "logical-vice": {
      "path": "images/logical-vice.png",
      "sha256": "1116789cee60f3dbe9c3738d5240534987436e22b615b3d9f0a279ab7012f605"
    }
  },
  "focusedResults": {
    "tests": 117,
    "counts": {
      "PASS": 112,
      "FAIL": 4,
      "SKIPPED": 1
    },
    "seconds": 14.599
  },
  "upstreamCaution": {
    "url": "https://vice-emu.pokefinder.org/wiki/Testbench",
    "checked": "2026-11-05",
    "observation": "The upstream TODO lists NTSC modesplit screenshots for checking and calls videomode reference results questionable."
  },
  "remainingEvidence": "A capture of the exact R04 binary on identified MOS6567R8 hardware, including separate A9/A10-sensitive ECM transitions, is needed to decide the combined-mode discrepancy."
}
